Skip to content
    Denver skyline over Sloan's Lake park
    Buyer & Seller Guide5 min read

    Questions to ask before hiring a Colorado listing broker

    November 17, 2026By Sarah Cowan · Sarah's Take, Broker Associate (CO License FA100037983)

    Last updated: November 17, 2026

    Years licensed is the wrong first question. Eight questions to ask before hiring a Colorado listing broker, from recent closings to how they negotiate.

    Ask the hard questions up front. The right broker will be glad you did.

    Most sellers ask one question when they interview a broker: how long have you been doing this? It's the wrong question to lead with. Here are the ones I'd ask instead, and why. (In Colorado, every real estate licensee is a broker, so "broker" and "agent" mean the same thing here.)

    1. How many homes have you closed in the last three years? In the last year?

    Years in the business count for something. Someone who has worked through several markets has seen things that a newer broker hasn't. But 30 years licensed with one deal a year for the last 15 is not the same as 30 years of active practice.

    Start with the last three years, then ask about the last twelve months. My rough floor is five closings a year, and that's the low end, unless the whole market has stalled.

    For transparency: I normally close somewhere between 24 and 45 transactions a year. This year I'll be closer to 15. It has been slow for most of us, and a good broker will tell you that straight instead of dodging the question.

    A simple deal almost runs itself. The moment there are moving parts, it's different. I just closed a transaction involving solar where the other broker, licensed more than 30 years but doing one or two deals a year lately, missed a contract clause that had been in place for two years. Current practice catches things like that.

    2. Do you work with buyers too, or mostly listings?

    Some brokers sell a lot of homes without spending much time with buyers. Volume from investor or property management listings is real business, but it's a different skill. If there are 12 comparable homes within a few blocks and a buyer has seen all 12, the broker who has been in those homes with buyers knows how yours stacks up.

    3. How will you market my home? Then ask yourself one question.

    Professional photos, MLS, social media, maybe drone shots or paid ads. How much of that you need depends on the house and the price point.

    The better question flips it back: when you've been looking at homes yourself, where did you look, and what caught your attention? If it caught yours, it's catching buyers' attention too. Then ask whether your broker does those things.

    4. Who do you think does this as well as you do?

    Plenty of brokers call themselves experts. Ask them to define it. Then ask them to name another broker they think does this as well as they do. Not because you're hiring that person, but because a confident professional can answer without flinching.

    When comparing production, know that on some teams every closing is recorded under the team lead's name, even when a different broker handled the deal. The numbers can make one person look bigger than they are.

    5. Can I talk to two of your recent clients?

    If you came through a referral, you already have that. If you found this broker cold, ask for two clients from the last year, or someone they're working with right now. Someone good at this shouldn't hesitate.

    6. If you're newer, who's backing you up?

    If you're hiring a friend or family member who is newer to the business, ask whether an experienced broker in their office can co-list with you. Read: Hiring a friend or family member who just got their Colorado real estate license

    7. What's negotiable in your listing agreement?

    Almost everything: commission, term length, how you get out, and who pays the buyer's broker. Ask whether someone in the brokerage can walk you through the agreement before you sign. Read: What's negotiable in a Colorado listing agreement

    8. Do I have to use the same broker to buy and sell?

    No. You're only committed to a broker you've signed an agreement with for that transaction. Read: Do you have to use the same agent to buy and sell your home?

    Frequently asked questions

    How many transactions should a listing broker close per year?

    At least five, unless the whole market has stalled. Ask about the last three years and the last twelve months, not just years licensed.

    Are years of experience the best way to choose a broker?

    Not on their own. Recent closings show whether a broker is current with today's market and contracts.

    What should I ask a broker's past clients?

    Ask how the broker communicated, how they handled problems, and whether they'd hire them again.

    Why do some brokers' sales numbers look higher than others?

    On some teams, every closing is recorded under the team lead's name, even when another broker handled the deal.

    Sarah Cowan, Broker Associate, Guide Real Estate (License FA100037983). 350 plus Colorado transactions. Serving the Denver Metro area including Jefferson, Denver, Arapahoe, Adams, and Douglas counties.

    Sarah Cowan

    Sarah's Take

    You are hiring someone to fight for you in a process you don't do every day. So ask whether they'll actually fight, even over $200. Maybe $200 doesn't matter to you. But you want to know the person in your corner will push when it counts and also tell you honestly when your expectations aren't realistic. A few weeks ago, my buyers made an offer on a home and the seller wasn't ready to deal. The listing broker told me, in writing, good luck putting my "hairy" offer together. A week later we made the same financial offer on a higher-priced home and closed. The first house is still on the market, now asking $4,000 less than what we offered. Ask the hard questions up front. The right broker will be glad you did.

    Thinking about buying or selling in Denver? Schedule a free strategy call.

    Schedule a Strategy Call
    Share:
    Sarah Cowan

    Sarah Cowan

    Broker Associate, Colorado Homes Denver

    Since 2011. 350+ transactions across the Denver metro. 5280 Top Producer since 2011. Direct strategy, honest pricing, and calm execution when things get complicated.

    hiring a broker
    listing broker
    Colorado sellers
    seller strategy

    Sarah Cowan is a licensed Broker Associate with Guide Real Estate, Denver CO. Equal Housing Opportunity. · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use